Miranda’s Plight

Manuel Miranda is a charming, avuncular GOP operative in his mid-forties who is known in Republican circles as Manny. In 2004, he enjoyed fifteen minutes of more widespread fame. Miranda, who at the time was the judicial nominations counsel to then Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist and the Senate Judiciary Committee, had downloaded memos detailing the Democratic judicial nomination strategy from an internal committee server and leaked them to conservative groups and the Wall Street Journal. When Mirandas role was discovered, Utah Senator Orrin Hatch called the act simply unacceptable. In the uproar that followeddubbed Memogate by the Washington pressMiranda was driven from his job in disgrace. The Hill later declared that he had one foot in the political graveyard.

Subscribe Online & Save 33%In some circles, however, Mirandas conduct wasnt exactly a death sentence. In February 2006, David Keene, the chairman of the American Conservative Union, spoke of Memogate when he presented Miranda with the organizations Reagan Award, saying, [Democrats] no doubt thought that it would all end with that, that Manny Miranda would slink off into the darkness and never be heard from again But it turns out that hes more than just a principled conservative: hes a man who doesnt know the meaning of surrender. Mirandas reputation for ruthless tactics and political skill, not to mention his formidable network of conservative contacts, ensured that his calls would still be returned. In the days after the Republican defeat in the midterm election last November, Miranda again picked up the phone. He had a big idea.

Miranda had observed the Republican meltdown over immigration from afar during the midterm campaign, and thought hed figured out a way to get the party out of its bind. His answer was to forge a grand coalition on the issue by bringing religious conservativeswho had withheld their considerable clout from the debate in 2006into the fold.

Thats not such a simple proposition. According to a Pew poll last year, close to two-thirds of evangelicals believe illegal immigrants represent a threat to American culture. On the other hand, a sizable minority of evangelicals believe their faith compels them to help immigrants in need. So Miranda, the deeply observant Catholic son of Cuban immigrants, came up with a compromise: a one-off amnesty for the undocumented relatives of U.S. citizens, in exchange for a permanent change to the Fourteenth Amendment that would deny citizenship to the American-born children of illegal immigrants. The bargain was a shrewd one. Conservatives who take a hard line on immigration are particularly enraged about what they call anchor babies: newborns who gain automatic citizenship and make it harder for the government to send their undocumented families home. At the same time, by offering a onetime legalization for the illegal relatives of U.S. citizens, Miranda was trying to address a major concern of those evangelicals who worry that a tough policy will break families apart.

By the weekend after the election, Miranda had developed a mission statement for a grand conservative alliance on immigration. Despiteor perhaps because ofthe Memogate affair, he was able to enlist some of the brightest lights in conservatism, corralling them at gloomy postelection conferences at think tanks and on the Hill. Miranda named the new venture Families First on Immigration. By the time he began discussing FFI openly in conservative circles, in early December, hed signed on a number of conservative icons: Keene; Gary Bauer, the leader of American Values; Lou Sheldon of the Traditional Values Coalition; Donald Wildmon of the American Family Association; and direct-mail pioneer Richard Viguerie. On January 8, FFI surprised Washington with a letter to President Bush and the new Democratic leadership. We believe that if we can leave the confines of this past years debate, we can help you formulate and win wide support for a coherent immigration achievement, the letter read. Mirandas ultimate aim was bold: to force presidential candidates to pledge to major immigration reform on his terms in the lead-up to the 2008 election.

Miranda has succeeded at these kinds of quixotic ventures before. A sturdy, round-faced man, he radiates the air of an efficient small-town mayor. Washington is filled with Friends of Mannystudents and activists hes nurtured into positions within the conservative establishment. Guys like Manny, they know the Hill. But its more than that, says Rabbi Aryeh Spero, the leader of Caucus for America, and another founding member of FFI. He can take an idea from start to finish, and make it work.

Miranda made his first foray into politics in the leadership of the Second Stewards Society, a controversial male-only secret society at Georgetown University. He graduated in the early 1980s and became a lawyer, joining the law firm White & Case. But he never quite left campus. Later that decade, he became head of the Cardinal Newman Society, engaging the conservative Catholic educational organization in the culture-war battles then gripping American universities. About ten years ago, he decided that Georgetown needed a conservative student womens group to combat the profile and feminist rhetoric of the campus womens center. Despite the fact that Miranda wasnt a studentor a womanhe wrote the organizations constitution and carefully vetted female undergraduates to front the group. Called the Womens Guild, it flooded the campus with a compendium of 1950s-era romantic advice, and although its membership barely cleared double digits, the Washington Post Style section devoted a front-page feature to the groupfailing to note Mirandas role in its creation.

After resigning from his Judiciary Committee job in 2004, Miranda faced unemployment and a Justice Department investigation. Neither slowed him down. He started an organization from his townhouse initially called the National Coalition to End Judicial Filibusters, later the Third Branch Conference, devoted to masterminding the conservative movements strategy on judicial nominations. As the groups chairman and only official staffer, he engineered two of the movements most acrimonious victories using his wide personal network, which includes conservative icons, many Second Stewards alumni and protgs, and numerous grassroots organizations. Despite the TBCs small size, he also became a reliable media expert on the subject of judicial nominations. In 2005, Miranda helped whip up pressure on Republican senators to support the so-called nuclear option, which would have ended the Democratic minoritys right to filibuster judicial nominations. The tactic allowed the GOP-controlled Senate to confirm several judges that Democrats had initially opposed, making Miranda a conservative folk hero. Later that year, Miranda organized the massive conservative opposition that led to the demise of Harriet Mierss Supreme Court nomination.

In some ways, FFI resembles Mirandas other successful ventures. For one thing, it has no full-time staffin fact, there dont appear to be any staffers at all besides Miranda. It also seemingly has no mailing address, Web site, official phone number, or public e-mail address. In other ways, its a departure. This time, Miranda is attempting an intervention rather than an attack, and already there are signs that his proposed compromise may be too clever by half. Richard Viguerie, for instance, objected to the limited legalization Miranda proposed in his January letter, stating that any Republican seeking the presidential nomination must hold a firm line on immigration. I know what Mannys trying to do; thats why I signed on to begin with. But theres a line here, Viguerie says. Any Republican candidate who tries to compromise on [amnesty] will lose in 2008, and I and a lot of others will work very hard to make that happen. And last month, when Miranda told the news organization Inter Press Service that if the Minutemen, the anti-immigration volunteer border patrol, agreed to our fundamental principles, they could join on, he was swiftly criticized by Hispanic evangelical leaders, who represent the fastest-growing segment of the evangelical population. Its great that white evangelicals are finally speaking out on this issue, says Rev. Samuel Rodriguez Jr. of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference. But so far, Im not sure Im comfortable with what were hearing. Miranda, who has never found a political dustup he couldnt win, may finally have met his match.

Support Nonprofit Journalism

If you enjoyed this article, consider making a donation to help us produce more like it. The Washington Monthly was founded in 1969 to tell the stories of how government really works—and how to make it work better. Fifty years later, the need for incisive analysis and new, progressive policy ideas is clearer than ever. As a nonprofit, we rely on support from readers like you.

Yes, I’ll make a donation