Germany’s Cassandra

Twenty years after the fall of the Berlin Wall, Günter Grass still thinks reunification was a bad idea.

I Am Martin EisenstadtUnterwegs von Deutschland nach
Deutschland: Tagebuch 1990

(On the Road From Germany to
Germany: Diary 1990, German Ed.)
by Gnter Grass
Steidl Verlag, 255 pp.

Twenty years ago, writer Gnter Grass, Germanys most noted Nobel laureate, began a special diary. The Berlin Wall, which had divided Germany for over a quarter century, had been torn down, unleashing huge questions about Germanys destiny and its place in the wider world. Grass felt that witness demanded to be kept. The opening of the German-German border gave him the previously unimaginable opportunity to travel through the German Democratic Republic during the brief, adrenaline-charged interregnum between the walls fall (November 1989) and unification (October 1990). During that period, Grassever the public intellectualwas not only an observer but, as he has been since the postwar fifties, an active participant in the debate over the historically loaded German Questions.

The publication this year (in German only) of the Grass diaries, Unterwegs von Deutschland nach Deutschland: Tagebuch 1990 (On the Road From Germany to Germany: Diary 1990), nearly two decades after German unification provide a thoughtful antidote to the flood of self-congratulation that is certain to accompany the anniversary celebrations this year and next. Those observations are stark, perhaps in retrospect overly so: Grass was one of the nations most outspoken critics of unification and its architectsU.S. President George H. W. Bush, and the special object of Grasss reprobation, conservative West German Chancellor Helmut Kohl, the undisputed father of unification.

It is hard today to imagine any other outcome than unification as it transpired, namely the eastern territories total incorporation into the Federal Republic and the united Germanys immersion in NATO. There are few today whod contest unification, whod wish there were two Germanys again. But it is worth remembering that many German leftists, particularly those schooled in postwar West Germany, initially balked at the prospect of reuniting Germany at all, which was still, as they saw it, atoning for the sins of its recent past. Gnter Grass, born in the Free City of Danzig (now Gdansk) in 1927, was a generation older than the skeptical baby boomers but no less cautious about rousing a virulent nationalism that postwar democratization may have mellowed but not purged.

In the diary, which is punctuated with Grasss own quirky ink sketchings, the then sixty-two-year-old embarks on a series of extended reading tours to eastern cities like Leipzig, Dresden, and Cottbus, as well as further-flung locales in the forests of Mark Brandenburg and along the coast of the Baltic Sea. He crisscrosses borders that had just weeks before been the Iron Curtainthe watchtowers still in placewhere good-humored East German guards just wave his car through. One asks to have a copy of The Tin Drum autographed. Grass remarks with consternation at the eastern Germans new obsession with products from the west, as if a carton of milk with advertising on it were better than milk from a state-run cooperative in unadorned packaging. The money, the moneys got to come, a Leipzig taxi driver tells him. It doesnt matter how; the main thing is the money.

Like just about everyone on the German left, Grass is shocked when the freshly liberated easterners throw their first democratic vote behind the West Germanbacked conservatives, spurning not only the Social Democrats but also the courageous dissidents who were the catalyst for the peaceful revolution of autumn 1989. The conservative landslide sets the stage for unification, thereafter a question of how and not whether. Grass shakes his head in disbelief as his good friend Willy Brandt, the world-famous Social Democrat and elder statesman, welcomes German unity, even appearing publicly alongside Kohl. Clearly, Germans are on a fast track to a one-sided unification.

Initially, Grass objects outright to settling the greatest of all German questionsthe nations proper borderswith a one-state solution. Now long forgotten, there was an array of options for the two Germanys under discussion in early 1990, including ideas of an independent, democratic GDR that coexisted alongside the mighty Federal Republic. Germany still owes a debt to humanity, Grass argued, namely the one it incurred as perpetrator of the Holocaust. Germanys division is the price it pays for Auschwitz. Like Brandts drop to his knees at the Warsaw Uprising Memorial in 1970, division symbolizes Germanys guilt and ever-present acknowledgment of its wrongdoing.

More to the point, Grass doesnt trust a resurgent Germany in the heart of Europe. Like the Poles he grew up with, he fears the reemergence of a bellicose patria, one that might even dare to return its capital to Berlin, to once again fly its national colors without shame, and even to send Bundeswehr troops into foreign wars. (There were mainstream voices in the ruling Christian Democrats who wanted to renegotiate Germanys eastern border with Poland in order to grab back territories lost in the war.)

But as the year 1990 advances, unification of some sort becomes inevitable. Grass adjusts to the possibility of a loose German federation composed of both Germanys federal states, under a new liberal constitution and geostrategically neutral. Yet this concept, too, bandied about briefly, is soon plowed under by the juggernaut of history, steered by Kohl and Bush. Grass is disgusted with his own Social Democrats inability to formulate a viable alternative to the chancellors Anschluss.

More than anything, the wests triumphal manner and the veneration of the deutschmark ber alles galls Grass. He watches eastern Germans buy into Kohls promise of blossoming vistas that are supposed to replace the grim wastelands of socialism. The easterners submit all too passively, he comments, merely exchanging one provider for another. The wests politicos shamelessly forgo the bare minimum of mutual respect: the promulgation of a new all-German constitution, something explicitly stipulated in West Germanys Grundgesetz in case of unification. The overnight introduction of the western currencyinstead of the gradual transition Grass, among many others, advocatedexposes the shaky, in-transition eastern firms to competition they cant withstand. The state-run companies begin to go under one after another, unemployment skyrocketing before the ink is dry on the treaty.

On October 3, 1990, Grass writes sardonically, Even a full moon on the Day of German Unification. Kohl gets his way on absolutely everything! Grassthe pessimist of the nation, as he is now calledappears on a prominent talk show that evening, the only reserved voice among the guests. It was right to spit on their jolly unification parade, he remarks to his diary.

So, twenty years down the road, is it not obvious who was right and who was wrongGrass, Germanys Cassandra, or unifications makers?

The first decade of unity turned out, as Grass predicted, to be a fiasco. Joblessness soared. Soon there were gaping black holes, desperate regions with 35 percent unemployment, galloping depopulation, and plunging birthrates. Instead of an aboveboard privatization of state enterprises, they were sold off for a song; most never resumed operation. The buyers origins told the story: 85 percent were western Germans, 10 percent were foreigners, and only 5 percent were easterners. On top of this, the Ossis were blamed for the mess, for being too dull-witted to pick up the tricks of the free market. (Indeed, the very name Ossi, which simply means people from the east, became something of a pejorative.) Unifications real cost, an astronomical bill that the wests taxpayers would foot, was only beginning to come into focus.

The second decade of unification, however, saw a more vigorous economic upturn in much of the east, a result in part of enormous subsidized investments in infrastructure. Joblessness, though still higher than in most of the west, has tapered off and fallen, though the black holes still exist. Cities like Dresden and Chemnitz (formerly Karl-Marx-Stadt) are boomtowns, with comparable per capita incomes to districts of western Berlin and the Ruhrgebiet. There is no hint of political instability even though the reform communist party has made a surprising comeback as part of the new Left Party. It capitalizes on the lingering resentment that sits deep among easterners across the political spectrum. The far right, too, though on the margins, musters support among the have-nots in those depressed regions where anybody with skills or an education picked up and left in the 1990s.

Grasss gloomy prophecies about a sinister German nationalism proved off the mark. There was never a popular appetite in 1989 or 1990 to snatch back swathes of Poland or centralize the state in the Prussian style. Postwar democracy and the processes of introspection set into motion by critically minded intellectuals like Grass (his 1959-published Tin Drum was a defining moment) had civilized German nationalism and undermined its expansionist logic. In fact, one could even argue that Germany is the model nation in coming to terms with an unsavory past. Neither Italy, Spain, nor Japan, to say nothing of the likes of Romania and Slovakia, has begun to confront its fascist collaboration the way Germany has, even if the process transpired in fits and starts, nudged along by intellectuals like Grass. Germans do wave flags nowand no one cares. NATO allies demand they send more troops to Afghanistans war zones, and it is the Germans who object.

Improbably, at the ripe age of eighty-two, this autumn Gnter Grass undertook another tour of eastern Germany. In the hardest hit of backwater ex-socialist towns, where crumbling housing blocks and empty storefronts still line the streets, he reads from his 1990 diaries and even does a little stumping for the Social Democrats. Still the hardheaded contrarian, he feels largely vindicated in his dark prophecies from twenty years ago. Germany may be united on paper, he argues, but resentment and income disparity still divide the nation. He sees the glass as half full, at best. Clearly, after more than five decades, Citizen Grass refuses to give Germanys powerful a free ride.

This site and all contents within are Copyright 1969-2011 Washington Monthly
Editorial offices: 1200 18th Street NW, Suite 330, Washington, DC 20036

Paul Hockenos

Paul Hockenos is a writer living in Germany. His most recent book is Joschka Fisher and the Making of the Berlin Republic.