It’s “Kennedy’s Call:” Oh, Brother!

Well, turns out the Wall Street Journal‘s live blog of the oral arguments before the Supreme Court on the constitutionality of the individual mandate may have created an excessively optimistic impression, in my mind at least. Most experts now weighing in are suggesting deep trouble for the administration, though some may simply be surprised that the issue isn’t a slam dunk, or think Solicitor General Donald Verrilli had a really bad outing (terrible timing, if true).

Jeffrey Toobin was the most categorically negative, saying in a live report for CNN that if he had to guess, he thinks the Court will probably strike down the mandate.

SCOTUSBlog’s Lyle Denniston was less negative about the outcome, but more certain about how the decision would likely be made: by the Court’s weathervane, Justice Anthony Kennedy.

If Justice Anthony M. Kennedy can locate a limiting principle in the federal government’s defense of the new individual health insurance mandate, or can think of one on his own, the mandate may well survive. If he does, he may take Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr., and a majority along with him. But if he does not, the mandate is gone. That is where Tuesday’s argument wound up — with Kennedy, after first displaying a very deep skepticism, leaving the impression that he might yet be the mandate’s savior.

Perhaps tomorrow’s hearing, on the “severability” of the mandate from the rest of the ACA, and on the constitutionality of its Medicaid provisions, will generate some new hints, but probably not. We’re in for a long wait–probably until June or July–with a truly momentous decision in very serious doubt, and the ever-erratic Kennedy in charge. That’s just great.

Washington Monthly - Donate today and your gift will be doubled!

Support Nonprofit Journalism

If you enjoyed this article, consider making a donation to help us produce more like it. The Washington Monthly was founded in 1969 to tell the stories of how government really works—and how to make it work better. Fifty years later, the need for incisive analysis and new, progressive policy ideas is clearer than ever. As a nonprofit, we rely on support from readers like you.

Yes, I’ll make a donation

Ed Kilgore

Ed Kilgore is a political columnist for New York and managing editor at the Democratic Strategist website. He was a contributing writer at the Washington Monthly from January 2012 until November 2015, and was the principal contributor to the Political Animal blog.