fbpx
  • The Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Political Animal
    • Politics
    • Washington Monthly’s 2020 College Guide and Rankings
    • 2020 Hospital Guide and Rankings
    • Economy
    • Education
    • K-12
    • Higher Education
    • Law and Justice
    • Health Care
    • Books
    • Group
      • Republic 3.0
    • Special Reports
    • Successes of Philanthropy
  • Column 2
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Careers
    • Privacy Policy
Washington Monthly
Donate
Subscribe
Share
Tweet
Print
Email

Why are Parkland Students So Articulate? Because They Were Taught Civics in Middle School

Students in Florida have benefitted from the country’s most successful effort to teach civic knowledge and engagement.

by Frank Islam and Ed Crego
March 5, 2018
Politics
generation Z protestLorie Shaull/flickr
Donate
Subscribe
Share
Tweet
Print
Email

The slaughter of 17 students and adults at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida on February 14 was, as we all know, only the latest in a seemingly endless string of recent mass shootings in America. But as many have noted, there is something different about this one. After past shootings, it was primarily adults—parents of slain students, gun safety activists, and so on—who spoke out about the need for government action to, say, ban the sale of assault-style weapons. This time, for the first time, it’s the surviving students who are leading the charge.

Even more striking is how passionate, articulate, and effective these students are in making their case. This was apparent in TV interviews within hours of the shooting. Indeed, one Stoneman student, senior David Hogg, had the presence of mind to interview his fellow students on his camera phone while the shootings were underway.

In the days that followed, as these young people went from giving local TV interviews to lobbying politicians in Tallahassee to beseeching Donald Trump in the East Room, their eloquence was so impressive that it fueled a far-right conspiracy theory that they are not real students but paid “crisis actors.” Mainstream observers have offered more plausible explanations. Broward County Schools Superintendent Robert Runcie, for instance, chalked up the student’s lucid activism to a district-wide debate program that teaches extemporaneous speaking. Yet, while that may be a factor, it doesn’t explain the fact that students at Florida high schools beyond Broward County have also spoken out, organized walk-outs, welcomed Parkland students to their schools, and gotten involved in other ways.

An alternative explanation that is worth considering is that the students at Stoneman Douglas, as well as all of the students in the state of Florida, have been the beneficiaries of what is arguably one of the nation’s most comprehensive and successful efforts to teach civic knowledge and engagement.

The roots of this effort go back to 2007, when former Senator Bob Graham (D) and former Congressman Lou Frey (R) realized that adults in the state of Florida scored at or near the bottom of surveys that measure civic health and engagement. The two joined forces and formed the Florida Joint Center for Citizenship to get civics education legislation passed. After a few failed attempts, in 2010 the Florida legislature finally approved, and then-Governor Charlie Christ signed, the Sandra Day O’Connor Civic Education Act, named for the former Supreme Court justice who has had made civic learning and engagement her post-SCOTUS life’s work.

Four aspects of the law make it unique. First, while most civics classes in America are offered, if at all, in high school, the O’Connor Act aims to educate students in middle school. It mandates a civics course in 7th grade and the incorporation of civic education content into the K-12 reading language arts curriculum. Second, while most states require that students be tested only in reading and math, the O’Connor Act mandates a comprehensive civics test at the end of 7th grade. That sends a message to teachers, administrators, and parents that civics is a core subject that needs to be taken seriously. Third, the act provided modest funding to the Florida Joint Center on Citizenship to contribute to the implementation of the legislation by providing assistance in areas such as professional development and curriculum development.

Fourth, while many of us may remember civics classes in our youth as dull and forgettable, the Act takes advantage of decades of effort by education researchers to figure out what works and doesn’t work to build the knowledge, skills and dispositions required for good citizenship. It advocates adhering to six evidence-based practices, including not just classroom lectures but teacher-led discussions of current events and controversial issues; extracurricular activities—particularly those requiring teamwork and collaboration; student participation in school governance; and, simulations of democratic processes such as mock trials.

The law was implemented in middle schools across the state beginning in 2011-2012 and the first testing was done in 2014. Evidence suggests the initiative is having a positive impact. The percentage of students who passed the state’s 7th grade civics exam has gone up from 61 percent in 2014 to 70 percent in 2017. At Westglades Middle School, which feeds into Parkland, scores were even higher: 86 percent, versus 70 percent statewide. Unquestionably, the students of Parkland had an excellent civics education even before they set foot in high school.

The message that civics education is vital and needs to be taught early is beginning to be heard. Two other states, Tennessee and Hawaii, now have middle school initiatives in place. The Illinois legislature is considering adding a provision on middle school civic learning to 2015 law requiring a semester long civics course in high school. And, Massachusetts has draft legislation to put a project-based approach to civic learning in grades K-12.

That’s the good news. The bad news is that Florida itself is going backwards. Last year, the GOP-controlled legislature and its governor, Rick Scott, cut funding for Florida Joint Center on Citizenship, the organization that supports implementation of the state’s civics program.

Nevertheless, Florida has set the example for the nation on what to do in civic learning and engagement. In these difficult times, our country should heed that example.

Support Nonprofit Journalism

If you enjoyed this article, consider making a donation to help us produce more like it. The Washington Monthly was founded in 1969 to tell the stories of how government really works —and how to make it work better. More than fifty years later, the need for incisive analysis and new, progressive policy ideas is clearer than ever. As a nonprofit, we rely on support from readers like you.

YES, I'LL MAKE A DONATION

Frank Islam and Ed Crego

Frank Islam is an entrepreneur, philanthropist, and thought leader. Ed Crego is a management consultant. They are co-authors of the book Working the Pivot Points: To Make America Work Again.

Related Posts

  • Penn/Flickr
    Biden's Education Secretary? The Case for Amy Gutmann, President of the University of Pennsylvania
    by Jonathan Zimmerman
    November 20, 2020
    | 3:08 PM
    The scholar specializes in bridging differences in a democracy, which is just what the riven ...read more
  • LiteracyAmeriCorps Photos
    What Happens to the Students Who Were Already Behind?
    by Jem Bartholomew
    October 29, 2020
    | 7:43 PM
    The pandemic has threatened literacy education. Here’s how tutors are fighting back.
  • Joshua Thompson
    For Profit College Execs Should Be Personally Liable For Their Crimes
    by Dan Zibel
    October 19, 2020
    | 8:00 PM
    Right now, they can walk away with millions. Fortunately, we can end that.
CG2020 Graphic Sidebar
Best Hospitals 2020 Sidebar w/ Lown

Newsletter

Get a weekly dose of our best stories in your inbox.

Sign Up-register for our free Weekly Wrap-Up newsletter.

Sign Up

Most Popular

Political Animal

Voter Suppression Is The Only Policy Agenda Left for a White Christian Identity Party

by David Atkins
February 28, 2021
| 4:39 PM

It will continue to be the number one GOP priority, regardless of how long Trump holds sway over the party.

Politics

Democrats Ditch 10-Year-Old Earmark Freeze, Putting GOP In a Tough Position

by Kevin R. Kosar
March 1, 2021
| 5:00 AM

Once reviled as "pork," discretionary spending provisions are once again seen as strengthening a broken Congress.

Politics

Democrats Form a Circular Firing Squad

by Bill Scher
February 26, 2021
| 4:30 PM

With the minimum wage, it’s time for them to turn the heat up on Republicans—not each other.

Political Animal

As CPAC Goes, So Goes the GOP. And It’s Not Looking Good.

by David Atkins
February 27, 2021
| 3:30 PM

Over the last decade, there's been no greater preview into the party's direction than the annual conservative confab.

Politics

A Free Market Won’t Self-Correct the Disinformation Problem

by Eric Cortellessa and Phillip Longman
February 27, 2021
| 5:00 AM

To stop the spread of lies and conspiracy theories, Congress should start by focusing on the media monopolies that give them an echo chamber.

Washington Monthly

Newsletter

Get a weekly dose of our best stories in your inbox.

Sign Up-register for our free Weekly Wrap-Up newsletter.

Sign Up
Donate
Subscribe
  • The Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Political Animal
    • Politics
    • Washington Monthly’s 2020 College Guide and Rankings
    • 2020 Hospital Guide and Rankings
    • Economy
    • Education
    • K-12
    • Higher Education
    • Law and Justice
    • Health Care
    • Books
    • Group
      • Republic 3.0
    • Special Reports
    • Successes of Philanthropy
  • Column 2
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Careers
    • Privacy Policy

© 2021 Washington Monthly.

Please support this website by adding us to your whitelist in your ad blocker. Ads are what helps us bring you premium content! Thank you!