fbpx
  • The Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Political Animal
    • Politics
    • Washington Monthly’s 2020 College Guide and Rankings
    • 2020 Hospital Guide and Rankings
    • Economy
    • Education
    • K-12
    • Higher Education
    • Law and Justice
    • Health Care
    • Books
    • Group
      • Republic 3.0
    • Special Reports
    • Successes of Philanthropy
  • Column 2
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Careers
    • Privacy Policy
Washington Monthly
Donate
Subscribe
Share
Tweet
Print
Email

Ignorance Ain’t Bliss

Inside the growing movement to improve civics education.

by Graham Vyse
September 27, 2019
| 5:00 AM
Politics
Hillary ClintonGage Skidmore/Flickr
Donate
Subscribe
Share
Tweet
Print
Email

Since the dawn of the Trump era, Democrats have offered a series of increasingly dire warnings about American democracy in crisis. Republicans are attacking voting rights. They’re neglecting election security. They’re defending the rigged system of gerrymandering that maintains their stranglehold on power. But last week, at a Constitution Day conference in Washington, D.C., speakers addressed another growing concern that underlies any conversation about the health of our body politic: the sorry state of civics education in America’s schools.

“It’s really an important issue,” former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton told me midday, as she picked up one of the unpretentious boxed lunches laid out for conference attendees at George Washington University, “because there does seem to be a disconnect between what people in our country know and understand about the way the government is supposed to work and how it actually works.” More fundamentally, Clinton said, “If people don’t know the basics of how democracy is supposed to function, it’s kind of hard to convince them on an ongoing basis that they have to be involved.”

This isn’t some far-off hypothetical from the woman most Americans voted to send to the White House. Just this month, the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg Public Policy Center reported that a mere 40 percent of American adults can name the three branches of the federal government. In February, the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Foundation found that most Americans in every state but Vermont would fail the U.S. Citizenship Exam. Research links civics education to voting, and America’s voter turnout lags behind that of most developed countries. Only 56 percent of eligible voters cast ballots in 2016. And roughly 40 percent vote typically in midterm elections, though turnout hit a historic 53 percent last year.

Improving civics education might sound like an old-fashioned solution to our present woes, and it’s certainly not a panacea. But the idea is gaining traction in Washington, and especially in the states, with support from Democrats and Republicans. “In the 2018 legislative session alone, at least 31 states proposed 115 bills or resolutions related to civics education,” the National Conference of State Legislatures reported. Of those measures, 15 were enacted. “That counts as something of a deluge for a niche policy area that has traditionally been favored by the earnest and the academic,” observed the 74, an education news website.

In the scope of recent American history, this is a new development. “For the most part, civics education has been cut over and over for the past few decades,” said Rock The Vote President Carolyn DeWitt, whose group creates and disseminates a high-school curriculum on voting and helps teachers register students to vote. “Today, we have 31 states in which students only have to learn about democracy for one semester and 10 states—20 percent of the country—aren’t required to take civics at all.”

The question of how, precisely, to change those numbers came up at last week’s conference, titled “In Defense of American Democracy,” sponsored by Clinton’s political group Onward Together, the American Federation of Teachers, and the Albert Shanker Institute. Michelle Burris, a senior policy associate at the liberal Century Foundation think tank, stood up in the audience to ask the morning panel about civics education “curriculum and pedagogy and promoting racially and socioeconomically integrated schools.”

MSNBC host Joy Reid, one of the panelists, responded: “When people don’t know what autocracy is, because they didn’t have a good civics education, people don’t even know what they’re buying into … I spend every weekend on my show re-explaining impeachment, because people don’t understand that impeachment doesn’t mean Trump gets fired. I keep calling it an indictment to put it in regular-people language, because people really think that if you impeach him he will go away.”

The cable news anchor floated a specific prescription: While Democrats had been “very reluctant” to champion a unified national curriculum, rather than allowing the current patchwork of approaches in states, it was time to embrace a nationally coherent framework. “In theory, a healthy nation should have one history,” Reid said, “and right now this nation has any history a school board wants it to have.”

Others are more skeptical. Leo Casey, executive director of the Albert Shanker Institute, told me that efforts to establish national curricula had “floundered” in the past precisely because education is a state and local responsibility. He said his group develops and distributes lesson plans for teachers to support civics education, but dismissed a “top-down mandate, which, by the time it gets to the classroom, is virtually non-recognizable.”

Agreeing on how to teach civics is a perennial challenge to begin with, especially in an era as polarized as ours. Another challenge for advocates is competing with more immediate issues of democracy reform in the age of Trump. “Election security is an imminent issue,” Casey allowed, “whereas civics is something where the positive effects will be seen over time.”

Clinton didn’t mention civics education in her address to the conference, focusing instead on election security, voting rights, gerrymandering, and online propaganda ahead of the 2020 election. But she did speak of “the responsibility that we have from generation to generation to pass on the fundamentals of our democracy.”

That message seems to be resonating. On Capitol Hill, a small group of lawmakers are getting behind national legislation. The Civics Learning Act, introduced this past January in the House of Representatives, would authorize $30,000,000 in K-12 civics-education funding. The bill now has 67 co-sponsors, including the GOP’s Tom Cole and Democrats Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Ilhan Omar, Katie Hill, Adam Schiff, David Cicilline, and Jamie Raskin.

In June, Republican John Cornyn and Democrat Chris Coons introduced the USA Civics Act in the Senate, aiming to “reauthorize and modernize an American history and civics grant program under the Higher Education Act,” according to a press release. That bill’s seven co-sponsors include 2020 Democratic presidential hopeful Elizabeth Warren.

As it happens, Warren is probably the candidate for whom talking up civics education would come most naturally. She’s already leaning into her identity as a teacher, and she could easily add this issue to a forthcoming K-12 education platform or her existing plan to save democracy. A more informed, engaged citizenry may not have the visceral appeal of taxing the wealthy or purging politics of big money, but this much is clear: it would be big, structural change.

Donate Now to the Washington Monthly and your gift will be doubled

Graham Vyse

Graham Vyse is a journalist in Washington, D.C., where he writes about media, politics, and polarization. His writing has appeared in the Washington Post Magazine, the New Republic, Washingtonian, and Governing.

Related Posts

  • Gerald R. Ford School of Public
    The Case for Neera Tanden
    by Matthew Cooper
    December 4, 2020
    | 4:35 PM
    After enabling Trump and fretting about political correctness, Republicans want to cancel the ...read more
  • NARA/David Hume Kennerly
    The Politics of Pardons
    by Martin Longman
    December 3, 2020
    | 2:40 PM
    Gerald Ford's pardon of Richard Nixon probably cost him his reelection. Trump's quest for the ...read more
  • How to Tell if Trump is Going to Win Pennsylvania
    by Martin Longman
    November 2, 2020
    | 8:51 PM
    Four years ago, Hillary Clinton lost the Keystone State by a mere 44,000 votes. Could Biden ...read more
CG2020 Graphic Sidebar
Best Hospitals 2020 Sidebar w/ Lown

Newsletter

Get a weekly dose of our best stories in your inbox.

Sign Up-register for our free Weekly Wrap-Up newsletter.

Sign Up

Most Popular

Law and Justice

Can Trump’s Pardons Be Reversed?

by Holly Brewer and Timothy Noah
January 22, 2021
| 2:07 PM

President Ulysses S. Grant did it, and George W. Bush, and the Constitution would seem to encourage it.

Political Animal

On the Way Out, Melania Seeks Distance from the Rest of the Family

by Martin Longman
January 20, 2021
| 3:15 PM

With her husband facing a second impeachment and the Trump Organization under intense legal scrutiny, the First Lady hopes for a less tumultuous future.

Law and Justice

No, You Can’t Carry a Gun on the Floor of the House

by Garrett Epps
January 22, 2021
| 1:28 PM

Rep. Lauren Boebert and other members of the shoot-'em-up caucus think they have an unfettered right to pack heat in the Capitol and even in the House and Senate chambers. They don't. Here's why.

Politics

A Great Speech

by Chris Matthews
January 20, 2021
| 3:10 PM

The veteran presidential speechwriter, author, and broadcaster says Joe Biden's inaugural address met the moment. Here's how.

Economy

The Facts About Biden’s Economic Agenda and the GOP’s Cynical Response

by Robert Shapiro
January 25, 2021
| 5:00 AM

Don't believe the Republican hype. It's a good plan that boosts incomes during the COVID crisis and paves a path to long-term prosperity.

Washington Monthly

Newsletter

Get a weekly dose of our best stories in your inbox.

Sign Up-register for our free Weekly Wrap-Up newsletter.

Sign Up
Donate
Subscribe
  • The Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Political Animal
    • Politics
    • Washington Monthly’s 2020 College Guide and Rankings
    • 2020 Hospital Guide and Rankings
    • Economy
    • Education
    • K-12
    • Higher Education
    • Law and Justice
    • Health Care
    • Books
    • Group
      • Republic 3.0
    • Special Reports
    • Successes of Philanthropy
  • Column 2
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Careers
    • Privacy Policy

© 2021 Washington Monthly.

Please support this website by adding us to your whitelist in your ad blocker. Ads are what helps us bring you premium content! Thank you!