While Biden Seeks Unity, Republicans Keep Getting More Toxic

It’s hard to build consensus when members of one party are putting their colleagues in physical danger.

It was 10:30 AM on January 13, 2021, and former Congressman Charlie Dent of Pennsylvania was appearing with CNN’s Erin Burnett and Anderson Cooper as they watched the House of Representatives impeach President Donald John Trump for a second time. Trump was charged with inciting an insurrection at the Capitol in a doomed effort to prevent Congress from certifying Joe Biden and Kamala Harris as the winners of the presidential election.

Republican Tom Cole, a jovial 10-term congressman from Oklahoma, had just spoken on the House floor: “Mr. Speaker, there’s still a way to unite the country. Let us look forward, not backward. Let us come together, not apart. Let us celebrate the peaceful transition of power to a new president rather than impeaching an old president.”

A little more than five years earlier, Dent, then a member of the centrist Republican Main Street Partnership and Tuesday Group, had been shaken by the resignation of Speaker of the House John Boehner who was under pressure from the GOP Caucus’s right flank for being insufficiently zealous. Dent recommended that Cole or 2012 vice-presidential candidate Paul Ryan succeed Boehner.

Ryan got the job, but proved too moderate for conservatives’ tastes and announced his retirement in April 2018. That was the last straw for Dent and, frustrated with the direction of his party, he quit mid-term in May 2018.

Now, a visibly upset Dent was telling CNN’s Burnett that no more than 10 to 20 of his former Republican colleagues would vote to impeach the president.

This is a time that I think that members need to stand up. Sometimes in order to save you know, they need to they shouldn’t be worrying about their jobs right now, they should be doing the right thing. They all know that…

…You know, I’m watching, right now, National Guardsmen, you know, sleeping in the Visitor Center of the U.S. Capitol right now.

The last time there were troops in the Capitol like this, stationed there, actually sleeping there, was right when Abraham Lincoln called the the troops to defend the Capitol. I know that because the first unit to respond was the Allen Rifles from my hometown of Allentown, Pennsylvania. This is a very critical moment for these members. You know, this is you know, they have to risk their jobs in order to save it. This is the time.

Dent’s gloomy prediction proved true. Only 10 House Republicans voted to impeach. As for Cole, despite his reputation for being a reasonable institutionalist he had joined the deniers and voted not to certify the election results in Arizona and Pennsylvania.  The 71-year-old with an MA from Yale later explained that he’d considered changing his position after rioters stormed the Capitol, killing one and injuring 140 Capitol Police officers, and terrorizing congressmembers and their staffs. “It was a tough call. I went back and forth on whether or not I should do it. But the sentiment in my district was very strong,” Cole said.

Perhaps Cole’s cowardice was explained by the fact that he and his staff had been trapped in his Capitol office during the insurrection. They listened to the terrorists call out his name as they pounded on his door.

Many Democrats share Dent’s disappointment with Cole. “A couple of them have had questions, and I’ve patiently sat down and explained to them,” Cole said.

But there’s no adequate explanation. It doesn’t matter what the sentiment is in Cole’s district. The objection to the certification of the presidential election was based on lies, and those lies led to an attempted coup.

That a consensus-minded institutionalist like Cole capitulated to the mob is an indicator of just how far the GOP has descended into madness.

More evidence of Republican decay came last month when Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi gave a press conference and announced the she would seek supplemental funding to protect members of Congress not only from future riots but from each other: “The enemy is within the House of Representatives, a threat that members are concerned about, in addition to what is happening outside.”

Pelosi noted that some in her caucus have purchased bulletproof vests because they’re concerned they may be shot by Republican colleagues. Of particular concern is Republican Congressman Andy Harris of Maryland who nearly started a fistfight on the House floor on the night of the insurrection and subsequently set off the metal detectors while illegally carrying a gun into the House chamber.

It’s hard to imagine relations between House Republicans and Democrats getting much worse. Cole describes the environment as “pretty raw” but says the country has seen more difficult times. Perhaps he has in mind the 1856 caning of Massachusetts abolitionist Charles Sumner on the Senate floor. If so, he has company in Republican Congressman Paul Gosar who responded when asked by the Arizona chapter of Oath Keepers, a conspiracy-minded quasi militia under scrutiny for fomenting the insurrection, if we’re headed toward a civil war by saying, “We’re in it. We just haven’t started shooting at each other yet.”

But at the White House the talk is still about unity and Press Secretary Jen Psaki goes to the podium each day to present a smiling, optimistic face to the world.

The contrast couldn’t be starker, and maybe President Biden and his top aides are naïve to think they can steer the government back on course and bridge the congressional chasm. It’s clear, though, that he has to try. Someone has to.

Support Nonprofit Journalism

If you enjoyed this article, consider making a donation to help us produce more like it. The Washington Monthly was founded in 1969 to tell the stories of how government really works —and how to make it work better. More than fifty years later, the need for incisive analysis and new, progressive policy ideas is clearer than ever. As a nonprofit, we rely on support from readers like you.

YES, I'LL MAKE A DONATION

Martin Longman

Martin Longman is the web editor for the Washington Monthly. See all his writing at ProgressPond.com