Before I get into the details, just answer that question. Should doctors be protected by law for withholding information from patients that their patients might want to know? Got your answer in your head? Here’s why: The Arizona Senate approved a bill Tuesday to shield doctors from “wrongful birth” lawsuits, which can arise if physicians […]
Aaron Carroll
Do People Who Want to Balance the Budget Hate Innovation and Capitalism?
Recently, I feel like I’ve been having the same argument over and over again. I start by agreeing with someone else that we need to find a way to reduce future health care spending. From there, though, it goes downhill. Every mechanism by which I suggest we reduce said spending is rejected by a “do […]
“Flexibility” May Be Necessary, But It’s Not Sufficient for Medicaid
There’s a piece by Kate Nocera out today on how states are taking advantage of Medicaid waivers in order to improve their outlook both now, and with the coming implementation of the ACA: Waivers must be “budget neutral,” meaning the state must create savings equal to any new federal spending. But the health care reform […]
Turns Out it is Hard to Cut Medicaid
Looks like Medicaid block grants are due for their turn in the spotlight again. Julian Pecquet notes that even some Republican governors are skeptical this time around. First, they don’t think they will be given the flexibility they need: Former South Dakota Gov. Mike Rounds, who also served from 2003 to 2011, raised concerns that […]
Added Sugars Are a Big Deal
As I continue my three month weight-loss kick, I could not help but be interested in a study from the CDC, Consumption of added sugar among U.S. children and adolescents, 2005-2008. Let’s start with a definition of “added sugars”: Added sugars include all sugars used as ingredients in processed and prepared foods such as breads, […]
Preaching to the Wrong Choir
I’m one month in another three-month commitment I’ve made with myself to do Weight Watchers (more on that later). One of the things the program always seems to reinforce with me is how much more important diet seems to be than physical activity with respect to weight loss. I’ve been active for quite some time, […]
Why It Would Actually Be Hard to Cut Medicaid
Given the discussions recently on the need to cut entitlements, and the inability to recognize so much spending as entitlements, it’s inevitable that eventually we will get back to discussing how we need to cut Medicaid. Every time someone suggests doing so, though, I start to cringe. I’ve long argued that Medicaid is almost the […]
More People Now Die in the US from Hepatitis C than from HIV
First the bad news: In summary, even if one cannot easily assign a cause of death among persons with HBV, HCV, or HIV infection, approximately 16 000 deaths among HCV- and HBV-infected persons were registered in 2007, and this figure must represent only a fraction of a larger burden of morbidity and mortality from viral […]
So Much for “Everyone Can Get Care in an Emergency Room”
We’ve long argued this meme isn’t true. But now it’s explicitly false: Last year, about 80,000 emergency-room patients at hospitals owned by HCA, the nation’s largest for-profit hospital chain, left without treatment after being told they would have to first pay $150 because they did not have a true emergency. Led by the Nashville-based HCA, […]
Will Mid-Level Practitioners Steal Our Business?
I’ve often written on the shortage of physicians in the US. Recently, Sarah Kliff posted on the upcoming debacle that might result if we don’t soon increase the numbers of primary care docs. One thing that might help is if we employed more mid-level practitioners, like nurse practitioners. This is opposed by a number of […]

