Posted inPolitics

Chris Hayes Echoes James Flynn: Meritocracy Won’t Happen: The Problem’s with the “Ocracy”

Chris Hayes rediscovers a point made several years ago by James Flynn. Hayes: The Iron Law of Meritocracy states that eventually the inequality produced by a meritocratic system will grow large enough to subvert the mechanisms of mobility. Flynn: The case against meritocracy can be put psychologically: (a) The abolition of materialist-elitist values is a […]

Posted inPolitics

Interpreting a Before-After Change as a Causal Effect: Campaign Spending and the Wisconsin Election

John quotes Seth Masket’s claim that it didn’t matter that the Republican outspent the Democrat by 7-1 in the recent governor recall election in Wisconsin. Masket writes: Walker and Barrett faced each other less than two years ago. Walker beat Barrett by five points back then, after raising $11 million to Barrett’s $6 million. That […]

Posted inPolitics

The Small but Important Group of Super-Rich Funders of the Democratic Party

Jay Livingston alerted me to this remark by conservative journalist Andrew Ferguson: That the “rich and powerful” are identical to conservatives and Republicans—Edsall’s assumption—is a hoary idea dear to many Democrats and essential to their self-image as the opponents of privilege. It persists even though many of the plushest and most powerful institutions of American […]

Posted inPolitics

Innumeracy Among Political Journalists

John Sides shoots down David Brooks’s claim that “If you look at the fundamentals, the president should be getting crushed right now.” John points out (as does Ezra Klein) that if you look at the fundamentals, you’d expect a close election. OK, there are lots of ways of looking at politics, elections, and the economy, […]

Posted inPolitics

The Difficulty of Preaching What You Practice

A couple months ago, in discussing Charles Murray’s argument that America’s social leaders should “preach what they practice” (Murray argues that they—-we!—-tend to lead good lives of hard work and moderation but are all too tolerant of antisocial and unproductive behavior among the lower classes), I wrote: Murray does not consider the case of Joe […]

Gift this article