WHAT IF YOU KNEW ALL THE STUFF THEY KNEW?….WOULD YOU STILL OPPOSE THE WAR?….This is going to be a bit of a long post, but I think it’s worth it, so don’t go away.
Brad DeLong, over on his immensely slow-loading Semi-Daily Journal, recounts this conversation:
Economics Professor:….I mean, I can understand that there might be secret intelligence to convince [the administration] that Saddam Hussein is too dangerous to be allowed to rule–that he is a madman with poor judgment about to embark on a career of terrorism and conquest–and that we need to strike to overthrow him as quickly as possible no matter what the United Nations thinks…
Interlocutor: And that secret evidence would be what?…
This is a serious problem for anyone not in the higher echelons of the government: they do have access to information that ordinary citizens don’t, and any serious anti-war partisan has to wonder if their mind would be changed by reading a few of the classified documents that these guys read on a daily basis.
Now, someone like Daniel Ellsberg would probably tell you that governments lie so routinely that you shouldn’t take a single word they say at face value. Unfortunately, assuming a priori that everything the government says is a lie doesn’t really get us anywhere either, and it turns out that Ellsberg himself has a much better and subtler argument for why your opinion ? even without access to classified information ? is probably as good as George Bush’s.
The explanation for this comes from Secrets, his book about the Pentagon Papers. Before we get to it, though, you have to first wrap your head around the rather unlikely setting for his explanation: a meeting with Henry Kissinger in 1967 when he was advising him about the Vietnam War. The idea of Kissinger seeking out Ellsberg for advice on Vietnam initially seems like something out of the X-Files, but in 1967 Ellsberg was a highly respected analyst on the war who had worked for both the Pentagon and Rand, and Kissinger was just entering the government for the first time. Here’s what Ellsberg told him:
“Henry, there’s something I would like to tell you, for what it’s worth, something I wish I had been told years ago. You’ve been a consultant for a long time, and you’ve dealt a great deal with top secret information. But you’re about to receive a whole slew of special clearances, maybe fifteen or twenty of them, that are higher than top secret.
“I’ve had a number of these myself, and I’ve known other people who have just acquired them, and I have a pretty good sense of what the effects of receiving these clearances are on a person who didn’t previously know they even existed. And the effects of reading the information that they will make available to you.
“First, you’ll be exhilarated by some of this new information, and by having it all ? so much! incredible! ? suddenly available to you. But second, almost as fast, you will feel like a fool for having studied, written, talked about these subjects, criticized and analyzed decisions made by presidents for years without having known of the existence of all this information, which presidents and others had and you didn’t, and which must have influenced their decisions in ways you couldn’t even guess. In particular, you’ll feel foolish for having literally rubbed shoulders for over a decade with some officials and consultants who did have access to all this information you didn’t know about and didn’t know they had, and you’ll be stunned that they kept that secret from you so well.
“You will feel like a fool, and that will last for about two weeks. Then, after you’ve started reading all this daily intelligence input and become used to using what amounts to whole libraries of hidden information, which is much more closely held than mere top secret data, you will forget there ever was a time when you didn’t have it, and you’ll be aware only of the fact that you have it now and most others don’t….and that all those other people are fools.
“Over a longer period of time ? not too long, but a matter of two or three years ? you’ll eventually become aware of the limitations of this information. There is a great deal that it doesn’t tell you, it’s often inaccurate, and it can lead you astray just as much as the New York Times can. But that takes a while to learn.
“In the meantime it will have become very hard for to learn from anybody who doesn’t have these clearances. Because you’ll be thinking as you listen to them: ‘What would this man be telling me if he knew what I know? Would he be giving me the same advice, or would it totally change his predictions and recommendations?’ And that mental exercise is so torturous that after a while you give it up and just stop listening. I’ve seen this with my superiors, my colleagues….and with myself.
“You will deal with a person who doesn’t have those clearances only from the point of view of what you want him to believe and what impression you want him to go away with, since you’ll have to lie carefully to him about what you know. In effect, you will have to manipulate him. You’ll give up trying to assess what he has to say. The danger is, you’ll become something like a moron. You’ll become incapable of learning from most people in the world, no matter how much experience they may have in their particular areas that may be much greater than yours.”
….Kissinger hadn’t interrupted this long warning. As I’ve said, he could be a good listener, and he listened soberly. He seemed to understand that it was heartfelt, and he didn’t take it as patronizing, as I’d feared. But I knew it was too soon for him to appreciate fully what I was saying. He didn’t have the clearances yet.
The bottom line is this: these guys do have information that we don’t have, and it does influence their decisions. But on broad issues like war and peace, it probably doesn’t matter. Unless they have some kind of smoking gun intel showing, say, that Saddam already has nuclear weapons with probability 1 ? and if they did they wouldn’t be fussing around with the UN in the first place ? that intelligence probably doesn’t give them a better sense of the big picture than any other knowledgable person.
So rest easy. You’re every bit as smart as they are.