The Danger of Vocational Universities

In terms of college goals, American policymakers must focus not just on educating people, but on educating people for specific jobs of the future, says the National Governors Association. Wow, that’s shortsighted.

According to an article by Catherine Gewertz in Education Week:

Colleges and universities must shape their work with a keen eye toward the demands of the marketplace, a new study from the National Governors Association tells us.

It urges governors to “align higher education with state economic goals” by letting colleges and universities know that they’re expected to contribute to their state’s economic well-being by helping prepare a 21st-century workforce. Governors should create incentives for their state colleges and universities to draw on labor-market research and employers’ input to help them set their priorities and to track their impact on student employment and employer satisfaction.

No, don’t. Just give up on this little hobgoblin. Train college students to think, train them to dream, and train them to work hard. The jobs will follow.

Now College Guide has pointed out before that there’s something very wrong with vocational education in America. One doesn’t need to go to college, but vocational, technical education is so bad in America that it’s actually quite difficult to get into a track for a high-wage, high-skill vocational career.

But the solution to this is to improve vocational schools so that they appropriately train people for existing jobs. The solution is not to turn American universities into vocational centers. Colleges and universities exist for a different purpose. Such institutions, frankly, should ignore jobs.

Especially the jobs “of the future.” The danger of the lure of vocational universities is not necessarily that such a focus will draw resources and attention away from the liberal arts and the hard sciences (disturbing as that is); the trouble is that focusing on the jobs of the future won’t work.

The report says that America’s governors should “encourage—even incentivize—institutions of higher education to seek state and regional employers’ input about how best to ensure that students have the 21st century skills employers need.”

The real problem is that we really have no idea what jobs will exist in the next 20 or 30 years. Just imagine what would have happened if governors in 1980 “worked to ensure that students have the skills employers of 2010 would need.” How would they know? Goals like this are impossible to achieve.

Trying to making an academic education directly about specific job skills is pretty much impossible. Train students to think critically. That’s the talent companies that hire for professional jobs want most anyway. Trying to do anything else at the American college is a waste of time.

Read the NGA report here.

Daniel Luzer

Daniel Luzer is the news editor at Governing Magazine and former web editor of the Washington Monthly. Find him on Twitter: @Daniel_Luzer