YEAR of meteors! brooding year!

I would bind in words retrospective, some of your deeds 
and signs;

I would sing your contest for the 19th Presidentiad;

I would sing how an old man, tall, with white hair, 
mounted the scaffold in Virginia

Despite his poetic claim to be “at hand…with teeth shut close,” Walt Whitman was not present in Charles Town, Virginia, on December 2, 1859, when the doomed abolitionist John Brown mounted the scaffold. Instead, he was at home in Brooklyn. Yet the political editor-turned-poet later became attuned to that day’s events, when the State of Virginia hanged Brown for his raid at nearby Harper’s Ferry. Brown had intended to spark a slave rebellion, but it was his spectacular failure that so intensified the sectional crisis, pitting the pro-slavery South against an increasingly antislavery North. The next year, when Whitman wrote the poem, “Year of Meteors-1859-1860,” he recognized the raid and its aftermath as the opening of what he termed “the 19th Presidentiad,” the 1860 presidential election.

Would the American sectional crisis and Civil War have looked different if Abraham Lincoln had failed to win the Republican nomination in 1860, or lost the election? Those rhetorical questions—we know, of course, what happened in the end—are worth asking, as is examining how Lincoln emerged as the unlikely nominee of a brand-new party and won a majority in the Electoral College against three major opponents, all of them in the North, with just 39 percent of the popular votes cast. His victory was the primary reason seven Southern states seceded from the Union before Lincoln even took the oath of office in March 1861. A closer look at the election of 1860 shows it unfolded at a particularly chaotic and unpredictable moment in U.S. politics, and historical contingency (the idea that past events are not bound by fate, but depend on specific human choices and chance occurrences) affected events at nearly every stage of the process, from the selection of the nominees, to the choice of locations for party conventions, to the strategies employed by all four candidates.

As Americans conclude yet another election season deemed especially pivotal, taking place during a period of intense political polarization and threats of violence, assassination, democratic backsliding, and civil war, it’s vital to remember that every election is inherently tied up with contingency. As chaos theory informs us, historical “butterfly effects”- the infinitesimal shift of wind created by the beat of an insect’s wing—can have cascading effects, eventually morphing into hurricanes.

Although a military failure, Brown’s raid confirmed Southern fears that abolitionists and their allies would go to any lengths to eliminate slavery. Many Northerners, impressed by Brown’s eloquence at his trial, shocked the South with their sympathy, both for the act of domestic terrorism itself and its morally compelling perpetrator. Ralph Waldo Emerson said Brown “has made the gallows as glorious as the cross.” In the South, newspapers declared that insurrections like Brown’s were the inevitable consequence of a radicalizing Republican Party championing the restriction of slavery. Even The Baltimore Sun, heretofore the voice of Border State centrism, announced that the South could not afford to “live under a government, the majority of whose subjects or citizens regard John Brown as a martyr and a Christian hero, rather than a murderer and a robber.”

 A hasty trial and conviction followed brown’s attack. Fearing that antislavery forces would attempt to bust Brown out of jail, Virginia Governor Henry A. Wise ordered 1,500 soldiers to Charles Town to maintain order. He also restricted attendance at the execution. Authorities were to arrest suspicious characters and loiterers on sight; no one was allowed within hearing distance of the gallows. If Brown uttered memorable last words, the governor intended for them to go unheard. 

The precautions didn’t stop an Ohio reporter, Murat Halstead, the new editor-in-chief of the Cincinnati Commercial, from slipping into town to witness Brown’s execution on December 2, 1859. Originally heading east to report on the opening of Congress in Washington, the 30-year-old Unionist and Republican journalist ignored his publisher’s advice (who feared he might be arrested or mobbed) and detoured to Charles Town.

Halstead was no supporter of Brown’s. He excoriated him as an “old man” with little actual Northern support. Halstead worried that acts by “madmen” and “fanatics”—in both North and South—were polarizing national politics and driving the nation toward civil war; above all, he was a Unionist. His journalistic goal—unusual in an era of partisan news coverage—was to be an objective eyewitness to events. Hence the risky detour into heavily fortified Charles Town.

According to Halstead’s account, Brown arrived at the gallows in a small cart sitting atop his own coffin. He exuded what the reporter saw as humble dignity, a contrast with the Virginia officers parading with their plumed hats and glistening swords. Halstead’s account of the hanging was concise but rich: “there was a moment of intense stillness, a sudden movement, a sharp twang of the rope, a creaking of the hinges of the trap door, and at fourteen and one-half minutes after eleven the old man, indomitable to the last, swung between the sky and the soil of the Old Dominion.” Before signing off, Halstead reported that, just before his death, Brown “turned sharply and faced North.”

As he wrote about Brown, Halstead wrestled in print with what Virginia should do with the perpetrator of an insurrection that highlighted the nation’s thorniest political issue. If Brown were set free, as many Northerners demanded, he likely would have planned more insurrections. Yet Halstead also recognized that Brown’s dignified martyr’s death achieved more for the antislavery cause than anything else during his tumultuous life, securing a “niche in the gallery of illustrious traitors,” as Halstead put it.

Northern papers picked up Halstead’s dispatches, elevating him to the ranks of a national reporter. During the following year, 1860, Halstead would cover the increasingly chaotic presidential campaign. He famously documented all seven major party conventions that year, including the Democratic Party’s implosion in Charleston, South Carolina; the birth of a new Constitutional Union Party in Baltimore; and the Republicans’ pivotal convention in Chicago, which nominated Lincoln. Halstead’s voluminous reporting and tireless travel to political conventions made him an indispensable chronicler of the pivotal election and, in the words of historian Garry Wills, “the classic reporter of our [political] conventions.”

In 1860, the young reporter would file tens of thousands of words of copy from each of the five (!) major party conventions—as the once-solid Democratic Party splintered into sectional factions, Old Whigs regrouped under the banner of “Constitutional Unionism,” and the Republican Party coalesced behind the unlikely Abraham Lincoln, a one-term congressman out of office for more than a decade.

The story of the election of 1860 exemplifies historical contingency: no one could have predicted or foreseen Lincoln’s election. Although he did his best to mollify his pro-slavery opponents, his victory directly caused the secession of seven states in the Deep South, jeopardizing the oldest republic in the Western Hemisphere.

Walt Whitman intuited that John Brown’s invasion was no butterfly wingbeat—that national politics was scrambled the instant the abolitionist occupied the federal arsenal located at the confluence of the Potomac and Shenandoah rivers on October 16, 1859. A year later, Whitman gave Brown’s raid celestial importance in his poem, conflating it with the “meteor procession”—an interplanetary rock fragmenting as it grazed Earth’s atmosphere. The spectacular event was witnessed across the nation, inspiring not only Whitman’s poem but also Frederic Church’s “The Meteor of 1860,” a Hudson River Valley landscape that portrays the event as a string of fireballs above the Catskills. Whitman and Church saw the explosive heavens as a metaphor for a nation entering a perilous moment.

Independent since 1969.

The Washington Monthly is nonprofit and reader-supported. Your tax-deductible gift pays for the reporting you just read.

Jonathan Earle is the Donald Cecil Delaune Professor and Dean of the Roger Hadfield Ogden Honors College at Louisiana State University, where he is also a professor of History and African American Studies and the author, most recently, of He Has the People:Abraham...