They still don’t know what Medicare is

THEY STILL DON’T KNOW WHAT MEDICARE IS…. Mark Blumenthal highlights the script of a new campaign commercial from Sue Lowden, the leading Republican candidate for the Senate in Nevada. Note the wording Mark bolded:

“As a mom I know one-size-fits-all clothes don’t fit, aren’t comfortable and are seldom a bargain. So why does Harry Reid want to force one-size-fits-all government health care on us? Harry Reid thinks Washington knows best, but I think we the people know best. Harry Reid’s big government health care plan will raise taxes, put a bureaucrat between you and your doctor, weaken Medicare, kill jobs, push us further into debt. I’m Sue Lowden and I approve this message because government run health care is wrong.”

The ad is filled with blatantly false claims, and the fact that Lowden repeated all of this to a camera, while keeping a straight face, is a little disconcerting. Indeed, the fact that Lowden thinks the health reform proposal being considered constitutes “government-run health care” suggests she’s deeply confused about the ongoing policy debate.

But it’s the bolded sections that are the entertaining part.

As a substantive matter, the right is foolish to characterize the Democratic proposal as a “government-run” plan. But the insult to intelligent viewers is made far worse when a Republican candidate bashes “government-run” care and praises Medicare at the same time.

I realize it’s awfully inconvenient, but Medicare is a single-payer, socialized-medicine plan. It works and Americans love it. (For that matter, the V.A. system is government-run health care, and it works well, too.)

Now, a wide variety of Republicans are willing to go on the record saying they’re anxious to weaken Medicare, and effectively eliminate the entire program. I happen to think that’s insane, but there’s at least a consistent strain of thought — far-right Republicans complaining about “government-run health care” who also want to scrap Medicare.

But Lowden, like a variety of her GOP cohorts, is playing a different kind of game, embracing and denouncing government intervention in the health care market simultaneously. Maybe this will fool some voters, but it shouldn’t.

Support Nonprofit Journalism

If you enjoyed this article, consider making a donation to help us produce more like it. The Washington Monthly was founded in 1969 to tell the stories of how government really works—and how to make it work better. Fifty years later, the need for incisive analysis and new, progressive policy ideas is clearer than ever. As a nonprofit, we rely on support from readers like you.

Yes, I’ll make a donation